• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Anthony's Pizza - Coatesville: Where Family Meets Flavor

Anthony's Pizza - Coatesville is a cherished local gem located at 6086 725 E, Coatesville, IN. This family-owned establishment prides itself on crafting fresh pizza dough on-site, ensuring every bite is delicious. The welcoming atmosphere enhances the dining experience, making guests feel like part of the family. Patrons rave about the quality of the pizza and the generous portions, often highlighting the delightful pepperoni sticks. With a self-service approach that streamlines the experience, Anthony's is perfect for casual outings, whether after a church service or a family gathering. The friendliness of the staff and reasonable pricing make it a must-visit destination for pizza lovers.

Photos & Gallery

Anthony's Pizza - Coatesville: Reviews & Ratings

William Ritcher
William Ritcher

Family owned. Crust is made on site. Friendly, reasonable price. The dining area is a clean, simple but comfortable atmosphere. We get pizza from here as often as possible! We took some out-of-town guests there. We had a table of 6, they treated us like we were family! I just can't say enough good stuff about this place... Love their Pizza!

Vince Wiscons
Vince Wiscons

An absolute gem in the middle of nowhere. Delicious pizza and great pepperoni sticks!

Kaiti Marie
Kaiti Marie

Delicious place! I come here after church as they open at noon on Sunday. Everything is fresh, hot, and delicious. Seating, drinks, and putting awaytrash are self-service, and they bring you your food lickidy split. Highly recommend!

Hannah Knotts
Hannah Knotts

We were greeted immediately and the guy at the counter was so friendly! The pizza was absolutely amazing and is probably the best pizza I've ever had. We took a chance on this place and we will be making it one of our regular stops. One slice of pizza and a breadstick filled me up, so you really get bang for your buck!

Jeff Lee
Jeff Lee

I won’t be that guy… but good food, large portions, great price so there is that. Dining in was interesting.

Cassie Hull
Cassie Hull

Stopped by this place for some dinner while staying with a friend near Heritage Lake. I thoroughly enjoyed the taste of my pizza. This place sells pizza by the slice, and they are huge slices. My only concern is that some slices looked like they were sitting there for quite some time. They do re-heat them for you so you're not served cold pizza. Eh, I still ate it and like I said it was great. Pricing is reasonable. Maybe next time I'll suggest that our group order a whole fresh pizza and split it. The fries were great, although I didn't love that the cheese sauce was nacho cheese. Personally I think that should be noted on the menu, at any place, if it's regular cheese sauce or nacho cheese. My daughter wouldn't eat any (and I bought for us to share) because she doesn't like nacho cheese. Still, for a small place in the countryside, it was pretty decent.

Lauren Cooper
Lauren Cooper

I like this spot a lot. It’s always clean and they’re always friendly. I can say this over and above- they’re always friendly. The food is fresh and good; often made to order. You can grab a wine cooler, how many places can you get the sweet perks of simple yesterday like a wine cooler? Not many. The man who runs the ship maintains the pace well, and I like his dedication. The salads are huge. I really like this. It’s a great spot.

christine b
christine b

I've had New York style pizza once while visiting N.Y. This pizza reminded me of that trip and I liked it even better. (I'm from the Chicagoland area, so, I grew up on Chicago pizza).

Location

If you're in Coatesville, Indiana, and you're on the lookout for a delightful pizza experience, look no further than Anthony's Pizza - Coatesville. Nestled at 6086 725 E, this family-owned gem is more than just a pizzeria; it's a gathering spot where warmth and delicious food intertwine seamlessly.

One of the first things you’ll notice upon entering is the inviting atmosphere. Juried by patrons' reviews, the dining area exudes a clean and simple charm that encourages you to sit back and enjoy a slice (or two!). The friendly staff greets each customer with a smile, embodying the essence of hospitality. Whether you’re dining solo or with family, you’ll feel like part of the Anthony's family from the moment you walk through the door.

Now, let's talk about the pizza. The crust is made on-site, a detail that pizza aficionados will surely appreciate. Customers rave about the quality—fresh, hot, and undeniably delicious. Many have shared their stories of devouring the rich flavors, from classic pepperoni to imaginative toppings that keep your taste buds on their toes. It's a slice of heaven that has solidified its status as a local favorite among both regulars and newcomers alike.

But the experience doesn’t end with the food. Reviewers frequently mention the generous portions and reasonable prices, making it a wonderful spot for families and groups. With self-service seating and a relaxed atmosphere, Anthony's handles busy Sunday lunches with grace, ensuring that your meal is served promptly without compromising quality.

In summary, Anthony's Pizza - Coatesville is more than just a place to grab a bite. It’s a beloved establishment in the heart of Indiana that brings people together over hot, delicious pizza and warm service. So whether you’re after a quick lunch or a cozy family dinner, this humble pizzeria will undoubtedly exceed your expectations with every bite.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards